| |
Editors
Note: The history of nuclear testing is a very large subject. Testing
went on for 48 years, and over a thousand tests were done by the
US alone. If you add in all other countries known to possess nuclear
weapons, the number of tests would more than double. It will be
necessary to set some limits regarding what this section will attempt
to cover. The early years, those in the 40's and 50's that led up
to the hydrogen bomb and the early improvements in it will be covered
in some detail. A brief description of each test shot will be provided
with as much information as possible. Only U.S. tests during the
17 years of atmospheric testing will be covered in this section.
Statistics
The
United States has conducted 1,054 tests of nuclear devices between
July 16, 1945 (at the Trinity site in the New Mexican desert) and
September 23, 1992 (at the Nevada Test Site). During the early years,
before 1962, all of the tests were atmospheric, exposed to the atmosphere
either on land or in the Pacific or Atlantic oceans, but overall
the majority were underground tests, 839. The vast majority of tests
were conducted at the Nevada Proving Grounds now known as the Nevada
Test Site, 928, but a number were conducted at various locations
in the Pacific, 108. Most of the Pacific tests were done at Eniwetok
- 43, Bikini Atoll - 23, Christmas Island - 24, and Johnston Island
- 12. A variety of means were used to deploy the devices for testing;
airdrops, tunnels, balloons, shafts, barges, towers, as well as
one on the surface of the ground and some rocket launched tests.
Between the years of 1951 and 1992 there were multiple tests every
year except for the test ban period of 1959 and 1960. The high point
was 1962, when 98 tests were conducted. Prior to 1965 the tests
were done in groups known as Series or Operations, which were named,
i.e.: Crossroads, Ivy, and Castle. Within these groups individual
tests were also named, i.e.: Able, Dog, and Nancy. The individual
tests are referred to by the name of the Operation or Series then
their specific name. As an example, Operation Ivy consisted of the
Mike and King tests, which are known as Ivy Mike and Ivy King. Some
Operations consisted of a dozen or more individual tests. The individual
bombs or devices (Not all of the tests involved bombs, many were
not usable as weapons, i.e. They couldn't be dropped from a plane
or fired at an enemy. They were experimental devices put together
to test subsystems or entire designs proposed for weapons use) being
tested were also named, many were numerical designations indicating
the style of bomb as well such as Mark 6 or Mark 14, abbreviated
as Mk-6 or Mk-14. After 1965 test series were divided by fiscal
year rather than operation. Each test was given a name and each
years tests were grouped under an Operation name corresponding to
a particular fiscal year. Tests were done for several different
purposes, which were divided into categories: Weapons Related, Safety
Experiments, Storage-Transportation, Plowshare, Weapons Effects
and Vela Uniform (designed to improve ability to detect and locate
underground tests). Data was collected on the tests and analyzed
by one or more of the National Laboratories, Los Alamos, Lawrence
Livermore, or Sandia. Originally the results of the tests were classified
but now a substantial amount of the material has been declassified
and released to the public.
In
The Beginning…
...there
was Trinity, the worlds first atomic bomb, tested successfully on
July 16, 1945. The device being tested, nicknamed Gadget, was an
implosion type with plutonium fuel and it had been hoisted to the
top of a 100 foot tower. A great deal depended upon the results
of this first bomb test, whether or not there would be an invasion
of the home islands of Japan, whether or not the $20 billion spent
on the Manhattan Project had been wasted, whether or not the bomb
would ignite the atmosphere and destroy the world (Fermi was jokingly
taking side bets). The Scientists at Los Alamos produced two bomb
designs, one using uranium 235 and another using plutonium. Little
Boy, the uranium bomb was a simple gun type weapon, which the scientists
were confident, would work and which did not require testing. Gadget,
the plutonium cored implosion bomb, was more complex. The design
worked by compressing the plutonium into a critical mass, which
could sustain a chain reaction. The compression of the plutonium
ball was to be accomplished by surrounding it with lens-shaped charges
of conventional high explosives, which had been precision cast for
the purpose. They were designed to all explode at the same instant.
The force was directed inward, thus crushing the plutonium core
and increasing the density of the sphere. This would have to be
tested, experimental verification of the projected results was important
since a number of new design principles were involved. Plans were
underway to test the device and from a list of eight sites in California,
Texas, New Mexico and Colorado, Trinity Site was chosen as the test
site. The area already was controlled by the government because
it was part of the Alamogordo Bombing and Gunnery Range, which was
established in 1942. The secluded Jornada del Muerto was perfect
as it provided isolation for secrecy and safety, but was still close
to Los Alamos.
In
the fall of 1944 preparations got underway at the site. A military
police unit arrived from Los Alamos at the site on Dec. 30, 1944.
The unit set up security checkpoints around the area and had plans
to use horses to ride patrol. It was determined however that the
distances were too great and they resorted to jeeps and trucks for
transportation and the horses were used for polo games with brooms
and a soccer ball. Throughout early 1945 other personnel arrived
at Trinity Site to help prepare for the test. An electric supply
system was built, a fire department established, water hauled from
the nearest town for drinking, gasoline and diesel was purchased
from the Standard bulk plant located in Socorro. A post office box,
number 632, was rented in Socorro so that mail service could be
established. Base camp was located 10 miles southwest of ground
zero. The George McDonald ranch house was located just two miles
from ground zero. McDonald ranch was used for assembly, the master
bedroom had been turned into a clean room for the assembly of the
bomb core. Contractors built two towers, one for Trinity and one
for the 100 Ton Test. In this test 108 tons of TNT were stacked
on top of a 20 foot platform at the top of a tower 800 yards south
of Zero. The purpose of this test was to calibrate the equipment
for the Trinity test. It was the largest conventional explosion
ever detonated. The tower at Zero was prefabricated and erected
atop concrete footings set 20 feet deep and spaced 35 feet apart.
A platform and shelter were placed at the top as well as an electric
heavy duty winch. Construction of the 100 foot tower at ground zero
was completed.
As
the date for the test approached a number of last minute problems
had to be addressed. By May 31 there was enough plutonium from Hanford
to begin experimentation to verify the critical mass. Robert Cristy
had designed the core as two solid hemispheres that were less than
critical until they were compressed to at least twice their original
density by high explosive surrounding them. The critical mass was
confirmed in experiments June 24. Very shortly before the test a
problem arose. The two pieces of plutonium for the core had been
cast and plated with nickel to prevent corrosion and absorb alpha
particles. Three days before the test the nickel plating began to
bubble up due to plating solution trapped beneath it. The resulting
bumps prevented the spheres from fitting together properly and had
to be ground down and the surface smoothed with gold foil. The high
explosive lenses that had been cast began arriving in June, produced
by George Kistiakowsky's team a number contained small air bubbles
and many were rejected for this reason or due to chipped corners.
Only perfectly shaped lens castings were to be used and there were
not enough of these as of July 9. Kistiakowsky finally resorted
to drilling into the castings with a dental drill and filling the
cavities with molten explosive slurry. He was able to rehabilitate
enough castings to make more than two complete spheres, each consisting
of 96 blocks. The material was a mottled brown color, somewhat waxy
and in total weighed nearly 5,000 pounds for each device. On July
10 a weather front moved in bringing bad weather.
On
July 12 the two hemispheres of plutonium were delivered to the McDonald
ranch. At the house, Brig. Gen. Thomas Farrell, deputy to Maj. Gen.
Leslie Groves, was asked to sign a receipt for the plutonium. Farrell
later said, "I recall that I asked them if I was going to sign for
it shouldn't I take it and handle it. So I took this heavy ball
in my hand and I felt it growing warm, I got a certain sense of
its hidden power. It wasn't a cold piece of metal, but it was really
a piece of metal that seemed to be working inside. Then maybe for
the first time I began to believe some of the fantastic tales the
scientists had told about this nuclear power." At one minute past
midnight on Friday, July 13, the explosives assembly left Los Alamos
for Trinity Site. Later in the morning, assembly of the plutonium
core began. Robert Bacher was the advisor; Marshall Holloway and
Philip Morrison had overall responsibility. Louis Slotin, Boyce
McDaniel and Cyril Smith were responsible for the mechanical assembly
in the ranch house. Assembly of the test device began at 1300 hours.
The team tried to use only tools and materials from a special kit.
Several of these kits existed and some were already on their way
to Tinian by different routes.
The
idea was to test the procedures and tools at Trinity as well as
the bomb itself. On July 14 the assembled core was driven to ground
zero for final assembly at the base of the tower. Holloway was responsible
for the mechanical assembly at the tower. The plutonium core was
inserted into the device with some difficulty. On the first try
it stuck. After letting the temperatures of the plutonium and casing
equalize the core slid smoothly into place. The next morning the
entire bomb weighing two tons was raised to the top of the 100-foot
steel tower and placed in a small shelter. A crew then attached
all the detonators and by 5 p.m. it was complete. Three observation
points were established at 10,000 yards from ground zero. These
were wooden shelters protected by concrete and earth. The south
bunker served as the control center for the test. The automatic
firing device was triggered from there as key men such as Dr. Robert
Oppenheimer, head of Los Alamos, watched. Many scientists and support
personnel, including Gen. Leslie Groves, head of the Manhattan Project,
watched the explosion from base camp. Most visiting VIPs watched
from Compania Hill, 20 miles northwest of ground zero.
The
test was scheduled for 4 a.m. July 16, but rain and lightning early
that morning caused it to be postponed. The device could not be
exploded under rainy conditions because rain and winds would increase
the danger from radioactive fallout and interfere with observation
of the test. At 4:45 a.m. the crucial weather report came through
announcing calm to light winds with broken clouds for the following
two hours. At 5:10 the countdown started and at 5:29:45 the device
exploded successfully. To most observers the brilliance of the light
from the explosion--watched through dark glasses--overshadowed the
shock wave and sound that arrived later. Those present were largely
caught up in the sense of anticipation, excitement, fear of failure…a
dozen conflicting emotions. It was not till after the fireball began
to rise that many of them considered what this event meant. This
was a revolution, a giant leap in destructive power. Its yield was
the equivalent of 21 kilotons of TNT. The crater left where the
tower had been was 2.9 meters deep and 335 meters across. Residents
of Santa Fe and El Paso could see the flash. The shock broke windows
120 miles away and was felt by many at least 160 miles away. Brigadier
General Thomas F. Farrell recalled:
In
that brief instant in the remote New Mexico desert the tremendous
effort of the brains and brawn of all these people came suddenly
and startlingly to the fullest fruition. Dr. Oppenheimer, on whom
has rested a very heavy burden, grew tenser as the last seconds
ticked off. He scarcely breathed. He held on to a post to steady
himself. For the last few seconds, he stared directly ahead and
then when the announcer shouted "Now!" and there came a tremendous
burst of light followed shortly thereafter by the deep growling
roar of the explosion, his face relaxed into an expression of tremendous
relief. Several of the observers standing back of the shelter to
watch the lighting effects were knocked flat by the blast....All
seemed to feel that they had been present at the birth of a new
age -- The Age of Atomic Energy -- and felt their profound responsibility
to help in guiding into the right channels the tremendous forces
which had been unlocked for the first time in history. (Photo)
The
world was now a different place than it had been, how different
would be demonstrated at Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Little Boy, the
bomb dropped at Hiroshima was a uranium fueled, gun type device
with a yield of 15 kilotons. Fat Man, the bomb used at Nagasaki
was a plutonium fueled, implosion type device which yielded 21 kilotons.
[ A section on the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombs and their human
toll is coming in the near future. The Webmaster] The end of World
War Two signaled the beginning of the age of nuclear weapons. Development
efforts for new, improved bombs began just weeks after the first
use of the weapon. Investigation of the effects of the weapons used
on Japan and exploration of various designs for more efficient,
more powerful devices would inevitably lead to the need to test
the resulting weapons and the new design principles needed to produce
them. On November 10, 1945 a subcommittee of the Joint Chiefs of
Staff was formed to plan for the first postwar series of test explosions.
In December President Truman issued a directive to hold joint Army
and Navy testing "to determine the effect of atomic bombs on American
warships." A plan was conceived and Truman approved the plan January
10, 1946.
The
Marshall Islands
The
Marshall's consist of 29 low-lying atolls and 5 islands covering
357,000 square miles in the Pacific Ocean North of the equator and
almost directly East from Guam. Divided into two chains, the Eastern
or Ratak group includes the atolls Mili, Majuro, Maloelap, Wotje,
and Likiep. The Western or Ralik group includes the atolls Jaluit,
Kwajalein, Wotho, Bikini, and Eniwetok. The islands rise only a
few feet above sea level and total only slightly over 70 square
miles. The current population is 65,507 (July 1999 est.) Sighted
by Spanish explorer Alvaro Saavedra in 1529 but Europeans did not
land there until the eighteenth century. In 1788 British named the
islands after one of their exploring naval captains. After having
been independent since the original Micronesian inhabitants arrived
from other islands, the Marshall Islands were claimed as a protectorate
of Germany in 1886 with the permission of the Chiefs of the Marshallese
and the British. An attempt was made by the Germans to colonize
the islands beginning in 1885, but this was unsuccessful. The islands
main product was copra produced from the abundant coconut crop from
the fertile Southern islands and atolls. In 1914, during World War
I, the Japanese seized the Marshalls. In 1920 the Japanese received
a League of Nations mandate and took over administration of the
island chain.
During
World War II Japan occupied the Marshall's and had their primary
installation on Kwajalein Atoll, with small outposts on a number
of the outlying atolls. As the war turned against Japan the United
States wrested the Marshalls from the Japanese in 1944. From that
point through the remainder of the war the islands were occupied
by the United States. The U.S. established the Pacific Nuclear Proving
Grounds in the Marshalls in February of 1946 beginning with Bikini
Atoll and then including Eniwetok in December of 1947. In 1947 the
United Nations designated the United States as administrator of
the Trust Territory of the Pacific Islands, which included the Marshalls,
the Marianas and Carolines. Under the trust agreement the U.S. was
permitted to close the Marshalls to ensure the security of the Nuclear
Proving Grounds. Article 5 entitles the United States to establish
naval, military, and air bases and to erect fortifications in the
territory. Article 6 obliges the United States to "promote the economic
advancement and self-sufficiency of the inhabitants ... regulate
the use of natural resources; encourage the development of fisheries,
agriculture, and industries; protect the inhabitants against the
loss of their lands and resources ... [and] protect the health of
the inhabitants ... ". Article 13 recognizes the authority of the
administrator to close areas for security reasons. A number of test
series were conducted at the Pacific Proving Grounds. In addition
to Crossroads in 1946 and Sandstone in 1948 there were Greenhouse
in 1951, Ivy in 1952, Castle in 1954, Wigwam in 1955, Redwing in
1956, and Hardtack I in 1958. The signing of the Limited Test Ban
in August of 1963 meant the end of atmospheric testing and therefore
the end of testing in the Marshall Islands.
The
U.S. continued to administer the Marshall Islands under the Trust
Territory until 1986 when Congress approved the Compact of Free
Association, approved in a plebiscite by Marshall Islands voters
in 1983. The Compact includes a Section 177 trust fund of $150 million
that is to provide $270 million in compensation payments over the
15 year life of the Compact (Bikini $75 million; Eniwetok $48; Rongelap
$37 million; Utrik $22 million; Nuclear Claims Tribunal $45 million;
$2 million annually for medical care for the "four atolls", and
$53 million for a nationwide radiological survey). The Compact includes
an espousal provision, prohibiting Marshall Islanders from seeking
future legal redress in U.S. courts and dismissing all current court
cases in exchange for a $150 million compensation trust fund. On
October 21 of 1986 the Compact took effect. The Marshall Islands
are now the Republic of the Marshall Islands with a constitutional
government in free association with the U.S. The Marshallese celebrate
the Proclamation of the Republic of the Marshall Islands, May 1
(1979) and October 21 (1986) their date of independence from the
US-administered UN trusteeship. The islands produce coconuts, cacao,
taro, breadfruit, fruits; pigs, and chickens and export fish, coconut
oil, fish, and trochus shells. President Imata Kabua (since January
14 1997) faces reelection November 1999 governs along with a unicameral
Parliament or Nitijela (33 seats; members elected by popular vote
to serve four-year terms). According to the CIA World Fact book:
US
Government assistance is the mainstay of this tiny island economy.
Agricultural production is concentrated on small farms, and the
most important commercial crops are coconuts, tomatoes, melons,
and breadfruit. Small-scale industry is limited to handicrafts,
fish processing, and copra. The tourist industry, now a small source
of foreign exchange employing less than 10% of the labor force,
remains the best hope for future added income. The islands have
few natural resources, and imports far exceed exports. Under the
terms of the Compact of Free Association, the US provides roughly
$65 million in annual aid, equal to about 70% of GDP. Negotiations
will get underway in 1999 for an extended agreement. Government
downsizing, drought, a drop in construction, and the decline in
tourism and foreign investment due to the Asian financial difficulties
have caused GDP to fall in 1996-98.
During
the period from June 30, 1946, to August 18, 1958, the United States
conducted 67 nuclear tests in the Marshall Islands, all of which
were considered atmospheric. The most powerful of those tests was
the "Bravo" shot, a 15 megaton device detonated on March 1, 1954,
at Bikini atoll. That test alone was equivalent to 1,000 Hiroshima
bombs. While the Bravo test is well known, it should be acknowledged
that 17 other tests in the Marshall Islands were in the megaton
range and the total yield of the 67 tests was 108 megatons, the
equivalent of more than 7,000 Hiroshima bombs. For the sake of comparison,
it may be noted that from 1945 to 1988, the U.S. conducted a total
of 930 known nuclear tests with a combined yield estimated to be
174 megatons. Approximately 137 megatons of that total was detonated
in the atmosphere. In other words, while the number of tests conducted
in the Marshall Islands represents only about 14% of all U.S. tests,
the yield of the tests in the Marshalls comprised nearly 80% of
the atmospheric total detonated by the U.S.
Under
Article IV of the Section 177 Agreement, The Governments of the
United States and the Marshall Islands agreed to the establishment
of a Claims Tribunal which would have jurisdiction "to render final
determinations of all claims past, present and future, of the Government,
citizens and nationals of the Marshall Islands which are based on,
arise out of, or are in any way related to the Nuclear Testing Program,
and disputes arising from distributions made under Article II and
III of this agreement." The Nuclear Claims Tribunal to address personal
injury and property claims resulting from the nuclear testing in
the Marshall Islands and provided for in the Compact of Free Association
was begun in 1988. Jurisdiction for all claims was invested in the
Tribunal. It was authorized to issue regulations specifying which
diseases were assumed to be caused by radiation exposure but was
urged by the scientist consulted not to do so. They recommended
that the Tribunal follow the precedent established by various courts
in radiation-damage lawsuits by requiring proof of causation or,
at a minimum, a demonstrated probability that a compensible medical
condition was the result of an individual's exposure to radiation
from the testing program. When the Tribunal approached the U.S.
government for exposure data they found that none was forthcoming
for any population other than Rongelap or Utrik. Without reliable
information about the exposure level of individuals who had been
living on other atolls, there could be no proof or showing of a
probability that radiation had caused the medical conditions suffered
by those individuals. This made it impossible to settle any of the
claims until an alternate method was discovered of establishing
causation.
In
late 1990, the Tribunal became aware of U.S. legislation known as
the "Downwinders' Act". Congress determined that fallout emitted
from the atmospheric nuclear tests conducted at the Nevada Test
Site had exposed American civilians "to radiation that is presumed
to have generated an excess of cancers among those individuals"
and based on that finding, a program had been established to provide
compensation for specified diseases to U.S. civilians who were physically
present in any "affected area" during the periods of atmospheric
testing in Nevada (between January 1951 and October 1958 or during
July 1962). The Tribunals enabling legislation had authorized this
presumptive approach. It addressed the need for a straightforward
means of determining which injuries could be attributed to radiation
exposure during the testing period while recognizing the impossibility
of an individual proving that their injuries or disease were due
to exposures to ionizing radiation. A list of 25 conditions was
drawn up which the Tribunal determined were compensible and the
area defined as affected was determined to be the entire area of
the Marshall Islands.
In
1991 the first awards were granted by the Nuclear Claims Tribunal
for injuries sustained during testing but due to concerns regarding
the adequacy of the $45 million allocated for the fund only 25%
of the total award is issued to claimants. December 1995 it was
announced that the Nuclear Claims Tribunal had awarded $43.2 million,
to 1,196 claimants for 1,311 illnesses. The fund was nearly depleted
and the Tribunal estimated in August of 1996 that $100 million in
personal injury claims will have been filed by the end of the Compact
period in 2001. This does not include land claims which are also
pending before the Tribunal. As of the end of 1997, net awards of
compensation totaling $63 million had been made by the Tribunal
to or on behalf of 1,549 individuals who suffered from one or more
of the 34 conditions then on the list. Two thirds of the awards
have been for thyroid disorders. The fund to pay the claims is limited
to $45 million by the terms of the Compact, however there is a clause
outlined in the 177 Agreement. Article IX of the Agreement is entitled
"Changed Circumstances." It provides that:
If
loss or damage to property and person of the citizens of the Marshall
Islands, resulting from the Nuclear Testing Program, arises or is
discovered after the effective date of this Agreement, and such
injuries were not and could not reasonably have been identified
as of the effective date of this Agreement, and if such injuries
render the provisions of this Agreement manifestly inadequate, the
Government of the Marshall Islands may request that the Government
of the United States provide for such injuries by submitting such
a request to the Congress of the United States for its consideration.
It is understood that this Article does not commit the Congress
of the United States to authorize and appropriate funds.
The
Changed Circumstances cited are the increased knowledge of the biological
effects of radiation since the original agreement and changes in
the maximum exposure level limits. In Article VIII of the Section
177 Agreement, the United States concluded, the Northern Marshall
Islands Radiological Survey and related environmental studies conducted
by the Government of the United States represent the best effort
of that Government accurately to evaluate and describe the radiological
conditions in the Marshall Islands. During 1995, a January 1955
report from the U.S. Atomic Energy Commission (AEC) entitled Radioactive
Debris From Operation Castle, Islands of the Mid-Pacific was made
available to the Republic of the Marshall Islands for the first
time. That report, which had been classified for 40 years, includes
tables listing radiation fallout doses as measured for 27 Marshall
Islands atolls for each of the six tests conducted in the 1954 series.
The cumulative doses contained in that report were apparently not
of great concern at the time, except for Rongelap, Ailingnae and
Utrik.
In
1957, the U.S. National Bureau of Standards published an addendum
to its report #59 for the National Council on Radiation Protection
(NCRP) in which a new public limit of 0.5 rem (500 mrem) per year
was established for maximum permissible exposure. Two years later,
in 1959, the International Commission on Radiological Protection
set a maximum general public limit of 0.17 rem (170 mrem) per year
(ICRP Publication 2). [It should be noted that in 1990 the ICRP
reduced the general public limit to 1 mSv (100 mrem) per year (ICRP
Publication 60).] The cumulative doses contained in the 1955 AEC
report for the Castle series are external only and do not combine
internal doses, as current radiation protection standards now require.
Also, for various reasons discussed in the report, the external
values given are, in general, underestimation's. It should also
be noted that the monitoring was conducted over only a 12-week period,
not an entire year. It is reasonable to assume that unmeasured radioactive
debris continued to fallout, in decreasing amounts, during the weeks
and months following the conclusion of the series. Nevertheless,
the exposure levels in that report show that 10 of the 22 populated
atolls listed exceeded the NCRP 1957 maximum limit of 500 mrem over
the period of an entire year for the general public and an additional
10 populated atolls exceeded the ICRP 1959 general public limit
of 170 mrem for a whole year.
Because
such information was not available to those negotiating the settlement
on behalf of the Marshall Islands, the U.S. assertion that the 1978
survey represented its "best effort" to describe conditions in the
Marshall Islands must be disregarded. In fact, the U.S. has still
not put forth its best effort to describe such conditions since
fallout measurements from the last two series of tests in the Marshall
Islands still remain classified nearly 40 years after the final
test, despite numerous requests made by the RMI government. Those
two series - - - Operation Redwing in 1956, comprising 17 tests
totaling 20.8 megatons, and Operation Hardtack I in 1958, comprising
33 tests totaling 28 megatons - - - had a combined yield greater
than the Operation Castle series in 1954. The fact that the exposure
levels sustained by people living on nearly every atoll in the Marshall
Islands in 1954 exceeded U.S. and international maximum permissible
levels established shortly thereafter clearly constitutes another
area of Changed Circumstances. And it can be expected that those
circumstances will change again when the U.S. finally makes available
exposure level data from the 1956 and 1958 series. A renegotiation
of the nuclear claims settlement based on the Changed Circumstances
provision contained in Article IX of the Section 177 Agreement is
clearly warranted. Without an extensive and impartial review of
the currently known damages caused by the nuclear testing program
and a substantial increase in the funding for payment of awards,
it cannot truly be said that the Agreement constitutes the full
settlement of all claims, past, present and future . . . related
to the Nuclear Testing Program (Article X of the Section 177
Agreement). The total money and non-monetary compensation paid by
the United States to Marshallese Islanders since 1956 to redress
damages from nuclear testing over $759,000,000.
Bikini
Atoll
Bikini,
a coral atoll in the Marshall Islands was chosen as the location
for the first test series due to its location away from regular
air and sea routes, accessible ports, and land for test installations.
It comprises a total of 2 square miles consisting of 36 islets on
a reef 25 mi. long. Bikini had held a small Japanese outpost during
the war but had long been somewhat isolated. It had been inhabited
for nearly 2000 years. In February of 1946 the U.S. Military Governor
of the Marshall Islands, Commodore Ben Wyatt, approached the atolls
residents and asked if they would be willing to leave temporarily.
They were told that their land was needed for the "good of mankind
and to end all world wars." The 167 people of Bikini and King Juda
agreed to do so. Residents of the Atoll were packed up and moved
to a nearby island, Rongerik Atoll, some 125 miles from Bikini.
Rongerik was uninhabited due to lack of water, small size, poor
food supply, and a native belief that evil spirits roamed there.
It was one sixth the size of Bikini. Within months the Bikinians
were starving and pleading to go back home.
In
March of 1948, on the verge of starvation, the Bikinians were taken
off Rongerik Atoll and moved to Kwajalein, where they stayed for
six months until another place was selected for their relocation.
The 184 Bikinians moved to Kili, an uninhabited island in the Southern
Marshalls in November of 1948. They remain there today. Numerous
difficulties have confronted them on Kili including typhoons, forest
fires, hunger, isolation and loss of their traditional diet and
culture. The hardships on Kili prompted consideration of yet another
relocation in April of 1952 and a number of alternatives were studied,
including moving them back to Bikini. On April 2, 1953 Bikini was
officially added to the Pacific Proving Grounds and the resettlement
idea was definitely dropped. In the end, several additional uninhabited
southern atolls were given to the Bikinians to attempt to provide
them with sufficient resources to live adequately independently.
In November of 1956 Bikini Islanders living on Kili are given $25,000
cash and a $300,000 trust fund (yielding about $15 per person annually).
The
original "temporary" removal lasted until the 1970s. A clean up
plan was developed and implemented to remove radioactive debris
from Bikini and work was completed in 1972. This work included the
construction of homes and planting of coconut palms and other food
plants. Some remaining radioactivity was discovered in 1972 and
questions were raised regarding the safety of the atoll for permanent
inhabitants. The majority of the Bikinians on Kili voted to delay
returning due to the new information, however they did not preclude
individuals from doing so if they so desired. In 1973 three extended
families of Bikinians moved back and began living in the newly built
housing development. Regular radiological surveys were conducted
to monitor the remaining radiation levels. In 1975 elevated levels
of radiation were detected and in October the residents filed suit
against the U.S. to force a complete survey. This was agreed to
by the U.S., but not begun for three years. Residents remained on
the atoll during this period. Finally in September of 1978 the people
were evacuated from Bikini due to alarmingly high levels of Cesium137
detected in the bodies of the 138 Bikinians. In September of 1978
The U.S. government funds a $6 million trust for the Bikini people.
A lawsuit was filed by the people of Bikini against the U.S. for
$450 million in compensation. The Bikinians filed a class action
law suit against the U.S. government in U.S. courts seeking $450
million in compensation in 1981. In response, the U.S. government
funded a second trust fund with $20 million in 1982 and latter added
an additional $90 million.
Disagreement
over the best method of decontaminating Bikini has been ongoing
since the 1980s. The leading council of Bikini has insisted that
due to the failure of the first attempt at resettlement, they wanted
the entire island of Bikini excavated and the soil removed to a
depth of about 15 inches. The scientific groups involved with the
Bikini project stressed that while the excavation method would rid
the island of the cesium-137, the removal of the topsoil would severely
damage the environment, turning it into a virtual wasteland of wind-swept
sand. Instead, they favor spreading potassium fertilizer over the
entire island. This method blocks the uptake of cesium by plants
and prevents its concentration in foodstuffs harvested from the
crops grown on the island. Development of the infrastructure to
support the cleanup and resettlement programs on Bikini Atoll started
early in calendar year 1991. The program was concentrated at Eneu
Island, which had been declared safe for habitation, and is the
main support base for the cleanup activities. The first stage of
clean up began in FY 1998 and included scraping of 300 acres on
the lagoon side of Bikini, which will become the housing development.
The crop producing areas will be treated with potassium.
Eniwetok
Atoll
In
July of 1947 the Marshall Islands and the rest of Micronesia became
a United Nations strategic Trust Territory administered by the United
States. In December 1947, Eniwetok Atoll was chosen for the second
series of nuclear tests because it is larger than Bikini, with more
land to build test facilities and emplace equipment. The AEC announced
the selection of Eniwetok Atoll as a site for proving grounds because
it "has the fewest inhabitants to care for and is isolated." The
U.S. government will transfer the Eniwetok inhabitants to sites
they will select and will reimburse them for the lands utilized.
The AEC explains that the establishment of these proving grounds
is necessary to provide a suitable area to verify by experimentation
"indicated results" of laboratory studies. Bikini is unsuitable
for such testing because it lacks sufficient land surface. Eniwetok
is 50 mi. in circumference and comprises about 40 islets surrounding
a large lagoon. The 145 residents of Eniwetok were removed to another
atoll, Ujelang. Operation Sandstone, the first test series at Eniwetok,
was scheduled to begin in April. AEC Chairman David E. Lilienthal
informed President Truman that to meet U.S. Obligations under the
Trusteeship Agreement, the U.S. government will accord "normal constitutional
rights of citizens to the Eniwetokese but will treat them as U.S.
wards; will keep displacement to the minimum required for their
safety; will resettle the Eniwetokese according to agreements reached
with them; and will provide adequately for their well-being in their
new locations." On April 28, 1948 the AEC went on record as desiring
that Eniwetok Atoll be retained as a permanent proving ground for
nuclear weapons after the completion of Operation Sandstone. Necessary
steps are taken over the next three years to finalize this arrangement.
Authorization
was given in September of 1948 for payment of $515,360 to the Eniwetokese
for the land area of which they were historic owners. The AEC refused
to make payments without legal proof of ownership and had made none
by August of 1951. In November of 1956 U.S. officials give the Eniwetok
Islanders living on Ujelang $25,000 cash and a $150,000 trust fund
(earning 3 1/3 percent annually) as compensation. On October 15,
1977 Public Law 95-134 authorized $12.4 million for rehabilitation
and resettlement of Eniwetok Atoll. The nuclear cleanup at Eniwetok
Atoll began in May. About 700 U.S. Army personnel carried out the
cleanup's first phase, which included scraping and collecting 100,000
cubic yards of radioactive soil and debris, and 125,000 cubic yards
of uncontaminated debris and removing it to a bomb crater on Runit
Island. The cleanup efforts continued for the next three years.
Then, the U.S. Defense Nuclear Agency announced in March 1980 that
the Eniwetok nuclear cleanup was completed. The estimated cost of
the cleanup and rehabilitation was $218 million. Eniwetok Islanders
began returning to the southern islands in the atoll at that time.
Rongelap
Atoll
The
people living on Rongelap were not permanently displaced during
the testing like those on Eniwetok and Bikini, but they were exposed
to large amounts of fallout as a result of the Castle Bravo test
in 1954. There is reason to believe that those in charge of performing
the test knew, or should have known that the Atoll would be subject
to fallout and did nothing. According to documents now available
in its preliminary radiological safety plan for the Castle series
the joint task force did not expect to evacuate native populations
before the Castle Series. The rationale for not conducting such
evacuations is based on February 1953 discussions between cognizant
headquarters sections, radiological documentation from Ivy, "apparent
unrealism in the assumption of health hazards of a magnitude conjectured
for Ivy" a policy of financial austerity for FY 1954, and the unavailability
of task force equipment for evacuations. The plan states, However,
consideration of populated islands will be one of the major factors
influencing the decision to shoot. Commenting on the proposals,
H. G. Hopwood, chief of staff for the CINCPACFLT, advises the CINCPACFLT
that the upwind populated areas present least concern since they
are situated in a potentially safe region but that the cloud
tracking within the danger area will not provide information useful
to CINCPACFLT in the discharge of his responsibilities for the safety
of other units and populated islands of the Pacific. . . . In the
remote circumstance that extreme post shot conditions develop a
necessity for the temporary evacuation of any populated island in
the Marshalls, units of JTF-7 would be required to accomplish this
emergency measure upon the request of CINCPACFLT.
On
February 28, 1954 at 6 p.m. weather reports indicated that atmospheric
conditions were getting less favorable. At midnight, just
seven hours from the shot, the weather report reports there were
less favorable winds at 10,000 to 25,000-foot levels. Winds
at 20,000 feet "were headed for Rongelap to the east." On March
1 Bikini's weather outlook downgraded to "unfavorable" and Joint
Task Force 7 directed several ships to move 20 miles to the south
to remove them from the expected fallout zone. Despite weather reports
showing that winds were blowing in the direction of inhabited islands,
the March 1 Bravo hydrogen bomb test was detonated at Bikini. Within
hours a gritty, white ash was enveloping islanders on Rongelap and
Ailingnae Atolls. A few hours later, American weathermen were exposed
to the snowstorm of fallout on Rongerik, and still later the people
of Utrik and other islands experienced the fallout "mist".
Those
exposed experienced nausea, vomiting and itching skin and eyes.
Estimates differ on the amount of radiation exposure received by
the Marshall Islanders. A military report made shortly after the
detonation suggests Rongelapese exposures of "150 R. whole body
gamma." Another military memorandum reports that 64 Rongelapese
may have received up to 130 roentgens over 51 hours; 17 additional
Rongelapese on Ailingnae, 80 roentgens in 58 hours; 154 Utrik residents,
17 roentgens in 78 hours; and 401 Ailuk inhabitants, not evacuated,
less than 20 roentgens total doses for their lifetimes. An Armed
Forces Institute of Pathology study estimates point source doses
at "260 R." for the Rongelapese and "20 R." for the Utrik group.
Later studies by the AEC/DBM estimate that some Rongelapese may
have received a whole-body gamma dose of 175 roentgens; that 20
percent incurred deep lesions; 70 percent superficial lesions; and
10 percent, no lesions; and that 55 percent lost some hair, which
regrew later. According to later estimates, the thyroid glands of
young Marshallese children absorbed approximately eleven micro curies
of iodine (131) and from 700 to 1400 rads. On March 2, 1954, after
the task force radsafe officer measures 0.200 R/hr at 500 feet in
a morning flyover at Rongerik, the radsafe officer evacuates 28
U.S. weather personnel from that atoll. An afternoon flight over
the populated Marshalls extrapolates 1.350 R/hr at ground level
at Rongelap; 0.400 R/hr at Ailingnae, 0.001 R/hr at Wotho, 0.240
R/hr at Utrik, and 0.076 R/hr at Ailuk. The flight over the unpopulated
atolls calculates ground contamination as 0.600 R/hr at Bikar Island
and Taongi Island at 0.014 R/hr. Task force officials then decide
to evacuate Rongelap, Ailingnae, and Utrik Islands. They sent the
destroyer USS Philip 43 nautical miles southwest of Eneu Island,
to evacuate Rongelap and Ailingnae the following morning and the
USS Renshaw, 13 nautical miles north of Eneu Island, to evacuate
Utrik on March 4, 1954.
Meanwhile,
radsafe monitors flown to Rongelap measured 1.400 R/hr in the living
quarters of Rongelap island. Rongelap islanders were finally evacuated
48 hours later, and Utrik was evacuated 72 hours after Bravo. Both
groups are taken to Kwajalein for observation. Skin burns on the
heavily exposed people began to develop, and later their hair fell
out. The U.S. Atomic Energy Commission issued a statement to the
press calling Bravo a routine atomic test , and stating that
some Americans and Marshallese were unexpectedly exposed to some
radioactivity. There were no burns. All were reported well.
On March 7 Project 4.1, Study of Response of Human Beings Exposed
to Significant Beta and Gamma Radiation due to Fallout from High
Yield Weapons, established a secret medical group to monitor
and evaluate the Rongelap and Utrik people. In April a Project 4.1
memo recommended that the exposed Rongelap people should have no
exposure for (the) rest of (their) natural lives.
On
April 29 a Department of Defense report states that the only
other populated atoll which received fallout of any consequence
at all was Ailuk...It was calculated that a dose...would reach approximately
20 roentgens. Balancing the effort required to move the 400 inhabitants
against the fact that such a dose would not be a medical problem
it was decided not to evacuate the atoll. In May Utrik Islanders
were allowed to return home because, according to U.S. officials,
Their island was only slightly contaminated and considered safe
for habitation. In July of 1957 Rongelap was declared safe for
rehabilitationin spite of slight lingering radiation. The
Rongelap people, who had been living temporarily in Ejit Island,
Majuro, returned to Rongelap. In a Brookhaven National Laboratory
report scientists state about Rongelap:
Even
though the radioactive contamination of Rongelap Island is considered
perfectly safe for human habitation, the levels of activity are
higher than those found in other inhabited locations in the world.
The habitation of these people on the island will afford most valuable
ecological radiation data on human beings.
The
first thyroid tumors began appearing in 1963 among the Rongelap
people exposed to the Bravo test in 1954. Also, a higher than normal
incidence of growth retardation among young Rongelap Islanders was
noted by U.S. doctors. In January of 1966 the U.S. Congress approved
an exgratia payment of $950,000 (about $11,000 per capita) to the
exposed Rongelap people for injuries resulting from their exposure
in 1954. In addition to the Marshallese the crew of the Lucky Dragon,
a Japanese fishing boat, were exposed to fallout from the test.
One crewman died and all suffered from radiation burns and sickness.
The amount of money paid by the State Department to Japan following
fallout from the 1954 "Bravo" test: $15,300,000
Operation
Crossroads
Following
the use of the nuclear bombs on Japan and the end of the war which
they brought about, U.S. military planners saw the future of the
military at a crossroads brought about by the new technology and
the tremendous changes it brought about. This was the origin of
the name for Operation Crossroads. That tests of the nuclear bomb
would be conducted was a foregone conclusion and had been since
the Chairman of the Senate's Special Committee on Atomic Energy
had proposed the use of captured Japanese ships to show the effects
of nuclear weapons in August of 1945. In September of 1945 the suggestion
was placed before the Joint Chiefs by the Commanding General of
the Army Air Forces. On December 10, 1945 President Truman announced
that the U.S. would pursue development and testing of the new weapons
under the jurisdiction of the Joint Chiefs of Staff. Crossroads
was the first test series conducted in the Marshall Islands and
the first since Trinity. Planned operations included detonation
of two devices in two separate tests code named Able and Baker.
The location to be used was Bikini Atoll and its lagoon, recently
vacated by the Bikinians. As a safety measure, islanders from Eniwetok,
Rongelap and Wotho atolls were also relocated from their homes for
the duration of Operation Crossroads.
Over
42,000 U.S. military and civilian personnel were involved in Crossroads
as well as 242 naval ships, 156 aircraft, 25,000 radiation recording
devices, and 5,400 experimental rats, goats and pigs. Crossroads
was a huge production. 90 vessels were set up as targets in the
lagoon including the following, all of which were sunk: the Sakawa
a captured Japanese heavy cruiser; the Destroyers USS Anderson and
USS Lamson; the Attack Transports USS Carlisle and USS Gilliam;
The Battleships USS Arkansas and Nagato a captured Japanese battleship;
the Aircraft Carriers USS Saratoga; the Submarines USS Apogon and
USS Pilotfish; and the Landing Craft LSM-60 (Surface Zero Ship for
Baker). Crossroads target fleet consisted of "older U.S. capital
ships, three captured ships, surplus U.S. cruisers, destroyers and
submarines, and a large number of smaller auxiliary and amphibious
vessels" provided by the Navy. Military equipment and ammunition
was placed on the ships to determine the effects of the nuclear
explosion on them and a number of amphibious craft were landed on
Bikini Island to be exposed to the explosions. A support fleet of
over 150 ships was used for living quarters, work space and laboratories
for the 42,000 men (more than 37,000 of whom were Navy personnel)
of Joint Task Force 1 (JTF 1).
The
taskforce was organized on January 11, 1946. Needs of the scientific
program of the test were considered in its composition. Joint Task
Force 1 comprised Army, Navy and civilian scientific personnel and
liaison was maintained with the War Department, Navy Department,
Manhattan Engineer District, and other governmental agencies including
the Joint Chiefs of Staff, the Presidents Evaluation Commission
and several national laboratories including Los Alamos. The Task
Force was divided into eight Task Groups, each of which performed
some specific function. Task Group 1.1 the Technical Group, was
responsible for placing instrumentation on the target ships and
areas. Some of the ships in this Task Group were equipped with laboratories
to aid in recording data. Task Group 1.2 the Target Ship Group,
was responsible for the target ships, sailing them to the test location,
and anchoring them in the lagoon according to the prepared plan.
Task Group 1.3, the Transport Group provided transportation to personnel
and equipment between the Support Fleet and the Target Fleet, and
between the Support Fleet and Bikini Atoll. Task Group 1.4, the
Army Ground Group, was responsible for providing and emplacing Army
equipment for the Target Fleet and Bikini Atoll, determining damages
from the tests, measuring radii of effectiveness for each detonation;
and loading, unloading and transport of all Army equipment. Task
Group 1.5, the Army Air Group, was responsible for dropping the
Able device, photography of the tests, transportation of observers,
and weather reconnaissance. Task Group 1.6, the Navy Air Group,
provided drone planes for monitoring of the radioactive clouds produced
by the weapons, aerial photography, and transportation by seaplane.
Task Group 1.7, the Destroyer Surface Patrol Group, furnished radiation
safety patrols, monitored arrivals and departures from the lagoon,
and deployed two destroyers to act as approach markers for the bombing
run. Task Group 1.8, the Service Group, provided base facilities,
food service, hospital facilities, shore patrol, recreation, construction,
shuttle service, general supplies and evacuation for Rongerik Atoll
population if necessary.
Crossroads
was to be well covered by the media, a contingent of 131 newspaper,
radio and magazine reporters from the United States and a number
of other countries were invited. Australia, France, Britain, the
Soviet Union, Canada and the Republic of China were all represented.
The correspondents were stationed aboard the USS Appalachian. Navy
and U.S. Government personnel were also involved in recording every
aspect of the tests on film. Eighteen tons of cinematography equipment
and more than half of the worlds supply of motion picture film was
on hand to record the movement of the Bikinians from their atoll,
and the Able and Baker test detonations. Scenes of the instruments
being prepared for the test, navy personnel playing beach volleyball
and swimming in their off hours, the target fleet floating in the
calm water of the lagoon were all filmed for audiences all over
the world. This was going to be a very big deal, they had carefully
planned to document the entire process. No aspect of the tests would
go without observation, analysis and comment by the Military, and
the public was to be included in much of it.
Vice
Admiral Blandy discussed the tests aim and the role of the press
in his press conference May 13, 1946. In this announcement the press
was told that they would have access to the general arrangement
of military equipment on Bikini Atoll, both before and after the
test and from the water and the air. They were told that "the basic
directives require that the test provide the essential data required
by the Armed Forces. The tests are primarily planned, therefore,
to determine and to measure with precision what happens at various
distances when an atomic bomb is used against ships and other items
of military equipment such as tanks, airplanes, radio sets, etc.
Much information of value to pure science will also be obtained,
and , where practicable, duplication or simulation is made of typical
operating conditions." It was pointed out that the ships had been
arrayed in the lagoon so that the maximum damage possible could
be inflicted on the ships clustered at the aiming point by one bomb
dropped from one airplane. The damage would progressively decrease
with distance from this central cluster. Planners intended that
the damage to the most distant target ships would be negligible.
Typical conditions were to be approximated by loading the ships
with combat supplies in differing amounts, some would be nearly
fully stocked, and others would be nearly empty, as ships would
be in the case of war.
Pains
were taken to emphasize to the members of the press that "there
is no thought of simulating an 'attack' by atom-bomb-loaded airplanes
against a disposition of ships at sea or at anchor in a harbor"
since the arrangement of ships had not been designed to approximate
any sort of natural conditions, but rather "to insure doing major
damage to a capital ship even if the bomb does not detonate exactly
over the bulls eye, and, second, to provide a positively identifiable
point of aim to the bombardier from a high bombing altitude. Other
steps being taken to place the bomb over the aiming point with the
extreme accuracy required in this test and not normally available
or essential under war conditions include: Painting the battleship
NEVADA at the center a bright red-orange, installing a radar beacon
on the NEVADA, providing special destroyer station ships as navigation
checks for the bomber's approach, and using precise radar methods
for obtaining accurate wind data at all altitudes over the target."
Some restrictions were placed on press coverage of the test, photographs
were to be examined by the military for the following reasons:
Photographs
produce exact and measurable records; analysis of large numbers
of related photographs of bomb damage can evolve much precise information.
While the press representatives who write for publication and broadcast
by radio will be permitted to do so without censorship of their
copy, the national security requires that all photographs be reviewed
for security and that the information obtainable from photographs
of damage be limited. Representative pictures showing damage will
be released as soon as practicable after the tests, some by radio
photo from Bikini. These pictures will be selected to provide the
public with a true graphic record of the general effects of the
test. Only such identification of ships and viewpoints in the photographs
will be released as will not prejudice the security interests of
our country.
Certain
other information was to be withheld as well, including: the exact
point of detonation of the bomb with respect to the point of aim
of the target array, the altitude at which the bomb is detonated,
the exact bearings and distances at which the ships are stationed
with respect to each other, the special equipment and techniques
used by the airplane involved in dropping this bomb, the exact pressures,
temperatures and other data obtained at various distances from the
point of burst, the degree of efficiency of the explosion, large
numbers of detailed photographs showing bomb damage.
Being
the first postwar test series, Operation Crossroads was bound to
attract a great deal of attention. This operation consisted of two
tests, Able and Baker. Each was a 21-23 kiloton device and the tests
were designed to demonstrate the effects of nuclear weapons on Navy
vessels. Crossroads was to be the first weapons effects test series,
intended to determine the effect of nuclear weapons on objects as
opposed to testing a new weapon design. Both the Able and Baker
bombs were nearly identical to the Fat Man implosion type devices
used at Nagasaki and Trinity, so no new technology was being demonstrated.
Two means of delivery were to be used, Able was to be airdropped
from a B-29 and Baker was to be detonated underwater suspended from
the Landing Craft LSM-60. Able was scheduled first, with Baker to
follow, on June 30, 1946 and July 24, 1946 respectively.
The
support fleet and all personnel were withdrawn to a safe distance
and the B-29 Dave's Dream made its pass and dropped the bomb which
airburst over the target fleet in the lagoon. Possibly due to crew
error or to the bombs tail fin having crumpled, the drop was off
the aiming point by 1,870 feet left and 980 feet short. Five of
the target vessels were sunk or damaged severely including USS Gilliam,
USS Carlisle, USS Anderson, USS Lamson, and the Japanese heavy cruiser
Sakawa. An observer located in a Navy plane 20 nautical miles from
the explosion submitted the following observations of the Able detonation:
At
twenty miles [it] gave us no sound or flash or shock wave….Then,
suddenly we saw it-a huge column of clouds, dense, white, boiling
up through the stratocumulus, looking much like any other thunderhead
but climbing as no storm cloud ever could. The evil mushrooming
head soon began to blossom out. It climbed rapidly to 30,000 or
40,000 feet, growing a tawny-pink from oxides or nitrogen, and seemed
to be reaching out in an expanding umbrella overhead….For minutes
the cloud stood solid and impressive, like some gigantic monument,
over Bikini.
Radiation
contamination of the target vessels decayed rapidly and was at 0.1R
24 hours after the test. Personnel were able to reboard the ships
the next day to perform examinations of the results. Damage to the
superstructures of the centrally located target ships was considerable,
however, there was negligible damage to the hulls of the ships even
those closest to ground zero. There were about 20 ships within half
a mile, all of which were badly damaged, many being put out of action
and five sunk. It required up to 12 days to repair all of those
ships left afloat sufficiently so that they could have steamed under
their own power to a major base for repair. Instruments were recovered
which revealed information regarding the radiation levels experienced
during the test. Analysis of these results brought the following
conclusions as described in the Preliminary Report of the Joint
Chiefs of Staff Evaluation Board submitted July 30, 1946:
Measurements
of radiation intensity and a study of animals exposed in ships show
that the initial flash of principal lethal radiation's, which are
gamma-rays and neutrons, would have killed almost all personnel
normally stationed aboard the ships centered around the air burst
and many others at greater distances. Personnel protected by steel,
water, or other dense materials would have been relatively safe
in the outlying target vessels. The effects of radiation exposure
would not have incapacitated all victims immediately, even some
of the most severely affected might have remained at their stations
several hours. Thus it is possible that initial efforts at damage
control might have kept ships operating, but it is clear that vessels
within a mile of an atomic bomb air burst would eventually become
inoperative due to crew casualties.
The
ships were inspected, some repairs and rearrangement of the target
array done, and where necessary the ships were remoored in preparation
for Baker. The preliminary conclusions of the Joint Chiefs of Staff
Evaluation Board of the results of the detonation were outlined
in their report:
As
to detonation and blast effects, where the largest bomb of the past
was effective within a radius of a few hundred feet, the atomic
bomb's effectiveness can be measured in thousands of feet. However,
the radiological effects have no parallel in conventional weapons.
It is necessary that a conventional bomb score a direct hit or a
near miss of not more than a few feet to cause significant damage
to a battleship. The first bomb, bursting in air, did great harm
to the superstructures of major ships within a half-mile radius,
but did only minor damage to their hulls. No ship within a mile
of either burst could have escaped without some damage to itself
and serious injury to a large number of its crew. Although lethal
results might have been more or less equivalent, the radiological
phenomena accompanying the two bursts were markedly different. In
the case of the airburst bomb, it seems certain that unprotected
personnel within one mile would have suffered high casualties by
intense neutron and gamma radiation as well as by blast and heat.
Those surviving immediate effects would not have been menaced by
radioactivity persisting after the burst.
The
bomb to be used for the Baker test was suspended 90 feet below the
surface of the lagoon in a waterproof caisson under LAM-60, which
had been anchored amidst the target fleet. Crews of the target ships
that had reboarded following test Able were evacuated prior to Baker
and taken aboard the support fleet which sailed east of the atoll
to observe the test. The Evaluation Board divided themselves into
two groups to observe the Baker test, one group of four watched
the test from the air at an altitude of 7.500 feet and the other
three were aboard the USS Haven, which was 11 miles east of the
atoll. The Baker test sank eight ships, including the battleships
USS Arkansas and Nagato (captured Japanese battleship), the Aircraft
Carrier USS Saratoga, the Submarines USS Apogon and USS Pilotfish,
the Auxiliary craft ARDC-13, the Landing Craft LSM-60 (Surface Zero
Ship), and the District Craft YO-160. The underwater detonation
resulted in the majority of the target ships being doused with radioactive
water and debris from the bottom of the lagoon. All but 12 of the
target ships were too radioactively contaminated to be boarded for
several weeks after the test, threatening the success of the test.
The test produced an entirely different sort of cloud than the airburst
of the first test. It was described as follows in the Preliminary
Report produced by the Joint Chiefs of Staff Evaluation Board:
The
visible phenomena of explosion followed the predictions made by
civilian and service phenomenologists attached to Joint Task Force
One. At the moment of explosion, a dome, which showed the light
of incandescent material within, rose upon the surface of the lagoon.
The blast was followed by an opaque cloud, which rapidly enveloped
about half of the target array. The cloud vanished in about two
seconds to reveal, as predicted, a column of ascending water. From
some of the photographs it appears that this column lifted the 26,000-ton
battleship ARKANSAS for a brief interval before the vessel plunged
to the bottom of the lagoon. Confirmation of this occurrence must
await the analysis of high-speed photographs, which are not yet
available. The diameter of the column of water was about 2200 feet,
and it rose to a height of about 5500 feet. Spray rose to a much
greater height. The column contained roughly ten million tons of
water. For several minutes after the column reached maximum height,
water fell back, forming an expanding cloud of spray, which engulfed
about half of the target array. Surrounding the base of the column
was a wall of foaming water several hundred feet high. Waves outside
the water column, about 1000 feet from the center of explosion,
were 80 to 100 feet in height. These waves rapidly diminished in
size as they proceeded outward, the highest wave reaching the beach
of Bikini Island being seven feet. Waves did not pass over the island,
and no material damage occurred there. Measurements of the underwater
shock wave are not yet available. There were no seismic phenomena
of significant magnitude. The explosion produced intense radioactivity
in the waters of the lagoon. Radioactivity immediately after the
burst is estimated to have been the equivalent of many hundred tons
of radium. A few minutes exposure to this intense radiation at its
peak would, within a brief interval, have incapacitated human beings
and have resulted in their death within days or weeks….the second
bomb, bursting under water, sank a battleship immediately at a distance
of well over 500 feet. It damaged an aircraft carrier so that it
sank in a few hours, while another battleship sank after five days.
In the case of the underwater explosion, the airburst wave was far
less intense and there was no heat wave of significance. Moreover,
because of the absorption of neutrons and gamma rays by water, the
lethal quality of the first flash of radiation was not of high order.
But the second bomb threw large masses of highly radioactive water
onto the decks and into the hulls of vessels. These contaminated
ships became radioactive stoves, and would have burned all living
things aboard them with invisible and painless but deadly radiation.
Decontamination
of the target fleet was begun in earnest on the first of August.
Crews of sailors from the target ships, supervised by radiation
monitors, washed the ships' exteriors. The work crews were divided
into shifts, each of which could only spend a very short time on
board the ship due to the severe contamination. The process of decontamination
resulted in radioactivity being brought aboard the support fleet
by accident as well as the low levels of radioactivity in the marine
growth and seawater piping systems of the vessels. On August 10
it was decided to stop the work and move to uncontaminated water
to continue the process. Surviving ships of the target fleet were
towed to Kwajalein during August and September where the decontamination
continued. Ammunition aboard the target ships was offloaded and
further decontamination efforts were made into 1947. Eight of the
larger ships and two submarines were towed to the U.S. and Hawaii
for intensive radiological inspection. Twelve of the ships of the
target fleet were unaffected enough to be sailed back to the U.S.
by their crews. The remaining target ships were destroyed by sinking
off Bikini Atoll, off Kwajalein Atoll, or near the Hawaiian Islands
during 1946-1948. Cost of 1946 Operation Crossroads weapons tests
("Able" and "Baker") at Bikini Atoll: $1,300,000,000.
Operation
Sandstone
Conducted
at Eniwetok Atoll in 1948, Operation Sandstone was the second test
series done in the Marshall Islands. Sandstone consisted of three
tower shots, all detonated at a height of 200 feet; X-Ray April
15, 37 kilotons; Yoke May 1, 49 kilotons; Zebra May 15 18 kilotons.
It differed from the first test series in several ways: it was primarily
a scientific series conducted by the Atomic Energy Commission; the
Armed Forces had a supporting role in Sandstone, whereas they had
assumed a lead role in Crossroads; and Sandstone was a proof-test
of second-generation nuclear devices. All of the devices previously
tested had been nearly identical copies of the weapon tested at
Trinity and used on Nagasaki. On April 3, 1947, the General Advisory
Committee to the AEC recommended development and testing of new
weapons. It was time to implement some of the design changes which
had been planned including a change in the core from the solid plutonium
core, surrounded by a close fitting natural uranium tamper developed
by Cristy to a new hollow design in which the solid core was suspended
within a hollow in the tamper. The new designs did not use a pure
plutonium core either. Oralloy, highly enriched uranium, was being
produced in substantially larger quantities than plutonium, which
made it a more attractive core material. X-Ray, used a composite
oralloy-plutonium core. Both Yoke and Zebra used an all oralloy
core. Other tested features included: trying different tamper thicknesses,
using different amounts of fissile material in the core, and testing
the effect of using a "minimum strength" polonium-beryllium Urchin
neutron initiator. Urchins containing the full load of 50 curies
of Po-210 had been used previously. Design parameters allowed use
of initiators with as little as 12 curies however, they had not
been tested. Because of the 138.4 day half life of PO-210, smaller
initiators would be help in keeping stockpiled weapons available.
The basic system used, the Mk 3 implosion style, was the same as
the previous tests. The Mk 3 bomb used for the Sandstone devices
was 60 inches in diameter and weighed 10,500 lb. total; the explosive,
core and firing system weighed 7,600 lb.
When
the President approved the preliminary Sandstone test program on
June 27 1947, the U.S. had only 13 nuclear weapons in its stockpile.
One year later, despite heavy emphasis on increased production of
fissionable material, the number of weapons was only about 50, far
short of the number that military planners calculated would be required
in a war with the Soviet Union. The great expansion in the U.S.
stockpile evident by the end of 1949 was the direct result of the
higher production rates of fissionable material and the more efficient
weapons designs proof-tested at Sandstone. The tests of Sandstone
resulted directly in the development of the Mk 4 bomb design and
the replacement of the entire U.S. weapons stockpile with bombs
modeled on the designs tested. The design features tested, including
the "hollow" core and using oralloy rather than plutonium for the
core had both been on the drawing board since Trinity, but the positive
results obtained in the Sandstone tests allowed them to be implemented.
The resulting increase in yield for the weapons in the stockpile
was 75%. Yields of the device in the X-ray test using a composite
core were the highest to that date, but was surpassed by the wholly
oralloy core in the Yoke device. The Yoke test set a record for
yield that lasted until 1951.
Meetings
were held on July 9, 1947 at Los Alamos, New Mexico, to define test
responsibilities for Sandstone. The Los Alamos National Laboratory
(LANL), the organization that had developed the wartime atomic weapons
and that did research and laboratory development of new nuclear
weapons designs, was to provide technical leadership and the military
services were to provide supplies and support. Numerous technical
experiments were conducted in conjunction with each of the three
detonations. These experiments measured the yield and efficiency
of the devices and attempted to gauge the military effects of the
events. The studies were similar at each of the shots but were carried
out more precisely with Yoke and Zebra as experience grew. Peak
DOD numerical strength at Sandstone was approximately 11,500 participants,
95 percent of whom were military personnel. The DOD personnel had
support roles and some had duty stations at the AEC weapons design
and development laboratories or were part of units performing separate
experiments.
Four
U.S. vessels arrived at Eniwetok on March 16, 1948, the command
ship of Joint Task Force 7 USS Mt. McKinley, the USS Curtiss a converted
seaplane tender used for storage and assembly of nuclear weapons,
the escort carrier USS Bairoko which carried the scientists in charge
of radiological safety, and the USS Albemarle which had been refitted
as laboratory space for the scientists from Los Alamos. Engebi island's
vegetation had been bulldozed and construct was progressing on a
200 foot steel tower set on a 600 foot asphalt pad. Half a mile
from the tower stood a reinforced concrete building built to house
electronic equipment to measure the phenomena produced by the detonation.
Other similar buildings placed at various distances from Zero held
equipment to measure blast and radiation. Five miles southwest of
the first tower on Aoman Island was a second Zero tower for the
second test shot and a shorter Navy radar tower modified to hold
photographic equipment. Farther south on the island of Runit was
a second pair of towers for the third test shot. Ten miles farther
south on Parry Island the main control center for all three shots
was located across from the main island of Eniwetok. General John
E. Hull was the commander of JTF7, he was headquartered on the Mt.
McKinley. Captain James S. Russell was the test director and Darol
K Froman the scientific director of the operation were both headquartered
aboard the Curtiss. The General inspected preparations for the tests
and final arrangements were completed by the Army Engineers under
Brigadier General David A.O. Ogden.
On
April 14th the firing party went ashore on Engebi for the final
check of the circuits, and the Task Force moved south across the
lagoon to prepare for the shot the next day. In the early morning
the firing party left the island and sped across the lagoon aboard
an aircraft rescue boat to the Parry control point. B-17 drone aircraft
began taking off at -30 minutes to get in position to sample the
radioactive cloud produced by the blast. The blast went off as scheduled
and within four minutes helicopters were heading to Engebi and technicians
in protective clothing were winching in a cable holding samples
from near ground Zero. A tank was being used to gather soil samples
from various points on the island by remote control. The drones
were landed and the filters removed with long poles. The samples
were loaded aboard a C-54 for the flight to Albuquerque. Speed was
essential as some of the fission products were short lived. By flying
them in relays, rather like the Pony Express, the samples reached
Los Alamos within 30 hours. Levels of radioactivity on Engebi were
low enough in a few days for the scientists to go ashore and recover
the test equipment. The second and third shots were done the same
way on May 1st and 15th . It took only a few days for scientists
to remove the equipment and within a week the support forces were
closing down the site.
Continue...
|